Where is the element with the id of "show"? I don't see it anywhere here.
You need to refer to the form elements by ID in your javascript
:
Here's what you could do with "comment-ajax.<acronym title="JavaScript">js</acronym>" to start tracing the error if there is a failure. Prototype fails silently (or with very little detail) unless you tell it what it should do when it fails.
In your HTML, add:
If you're using firebug, replace all
with
(Remove all references to "debug" when your app goes into public use, or wrap your debugging log functions into a separate function that you can disable when your app goes live)
-Kris