[Canukiwi]

Gidday! I'm evaluating a couple of different CMS systems for my fraternity's alumni association web site. Wondering if you could send me (or post) your opinions on the following when you have a chance:

PostNuke
e107
PhpNuke

PhPNuke has the advantage of the DaDaBIK plugin, but I could integrate the full aDaBIK app into one of the others. I would need facility to allow users to edit their profiles, and also have people be able to look at certain years. I'm thinking I'll be customizing it eventually but...

Thanks in advance for all replies! I'll summarize responses in a week or so.

K1W1

[Stefan]

phpNuke also has the downside of not being the most stable and secure app in the list. but of course, if it suits your needs, why not go for it. I personally feel, however, that postNuke is a very good alternative.

[clintre]

You will hear a lot of opinions on this because there are alot of people enamored with a specific portal app. I for one try not to use the nukes for most of the sites I have built simply because they are so bloated with stuff 99% of the people will never use.

Saying that I have worked with both major nukes PHPNUKE and Post Nuke and would have to lean towards Post Nuke from what I have seen. Both have huge community followings and thus it is easy to get support, but Post Nuke seems to be more stable "out of the box" than php nuke.

e107 seems to be a good alternative, but I can not say that I have used it in a production environment. I have only played around with it on a dev server at home.

TikiWiki looks promising but is VERY buggy from what I have heard and the little I have played with it. Someone can correct me if I am wrong or has a diferent opinion.

That is my 2 cents!