I am very new to Flash. I'm investigating tools to make games. I was unable to complete this tutorial because the author began to get confusing with the instructions....and there are a lot of little clicks here, clicks there, f3 here, f8 there. I think just a little more care with the reader would make this a good tutorial. I would have rated this a 4 if i had at least been able to complete the tutorial, but I don't give it lower than a 3 because i did learn something. So, i rate it a 3